Sweet Potato Casserole with Marshmallow

The first time I made sweet potato casserole was during an unexpected snowstorm that kept everyone indoors for Thanksgiving. The power flickered as I boiled those orange chunks, and we all huddled around the oven's warmth while the marshmallows bubbled and browned. Something about that cozy desperation turned this simple dish into our family's most requested holiday tradition.

My nephew Tommy, who survived solely on chicken nuggets for three years, shocked us all by requesting seconds of this casserole last Christmas. The room fell silent as he scooped another helping, and my sister-in-law mouthed thank you across the table while pretending to wipe away a tear. Sometimes victory comes in small, marshmallow-topped moments.

Ingredients

• Sweet potatoes: Look for ones with deep orange flesh and no soft spots, as Ive found the deeper the color, the sweeter and more flavorful theyll be.
• Brown sugar: Light brown gives just the right caramel notes without overpowering the natural sweetness of the potatoes.
• Spices: The cinnamon-nutmeg combo transforms this from basic to memorable, creating that warm aroma that fills the kitchen.
• Mini marshmallows: These little pillows of joy melt more evenly than large ones, creating that perfect golden crust we all secretly fight over.

Instructions

Prep your potatoes:

Peel and chunk those sweet potatoes into roughly equal pieces so they cook evenly. The water should just cover them when you set them to boil.

Create the creamy base:

After draining, mash while theyre still hot for the smoothest texture. You should feel a satisfying resistance that gives way to silky creaminess.

Mix in the magic:

When incorporating the butter, milk, and seasonings, the mixture will transform before your eyes. The aroma of vanilla and cinnamon will signal youre on the right track.

First bake:

Spread the mixture evenly in your dish with a gentle touch. Those 25 minutes of initial baking allow the flavors to deepen and meld together.

Marshmallow moment:

Scatter those mini marshmallows with joyful abandon, covering every inch. This is the moment my kids always volunteer to help.

Golden finish:

Keep a close eye during the final baking as marshmallows can go from perfectly golden to charred in moments. The ideal color is like a summer sunset.

Save to Pinterest

Last Thanksgiving, my normally stoic father-in-law took his first bite of this casserole and suddenly launched into a story about how his grandmother made something similar when he was a boy. In thirty years of marriage, Id never heard this story before, and around the table, we all fell quiet, watching him travel back through time with each sweet, nostalgic forkful.

Make-Ahead Options

The sweet potato base can be made up to two days in advance and stored covered in the refrigerator, which actually improves the flavor as the spices have time to deepen. Just bring it to room temperature before baking, add those marshmallows fresh, and proceed with the final baking steps when youre ready to serve.

Serving Suggestions

Theres something magical about how this casserole complements savory turkey and tangy cranberry sauce, creating that perfect bite. Ive also served it alongside glazed ham during Easter, where the sweet-on-sweet combination somehow works beautifully, especially with a crisp green vegetable to balance the plate.

Customizing Your Casserole

Over the years, Ive experimented with countless variations, from adding orange zest for brightness to incorporating bourbon for depth. The beauty of this recipe is how wonderfully it adapts to your personal taste preferences while maintaining its comforting soul.

• For a delightful textural contrast, sprinkle chopped pecans or a simple streusel between the sweet potato layer and marshmallows.
• If youre serving adults only, a tablespoon of bourbon or dark rum stirred into the mixture adds sophisticated depth.
• For a lighter version that still satisfies, reduce the sugar by half and add a teaspoon of maple extract.

Save to Pinterest

There are recipes that feed, and then there are recipes that gather people together, creating moments that linger long after the plates are cleared. This sweet potato casserole belongs firmly in the latter category.

Your Recipe Questions Answered

→ Can I make this ahead of time?

Yes, you can prepare the sweet potato mixture up to 2 days ahead and refrigerate it covered. Add the marshmallows just before baking for best results.

→ How do I prevent the marshmallows from burning?

Watch closely during the final 10-15 minutes of baking. If marshmallows are browning too quickly, cover loosely with foil and reduce oven temperature by 25°F.

→ Can I use fresh sweet potato instead of canned?

Absolutely. Boil peeled and chunked fresh sweet potatoes until very tender (15-20 minutes), then drain and mash thoroughly for the smoothest texture.

→ Is this dish dairy-free friendly?

Yes, substitute plant-based butter and non-dairy milk. Check marshmallow labels for gelatin, and choose vegan versions if needed for dietary restrictions.

→ What spices pair well with sweet potatoes?

Beyond cinnamon and nutmeg, try ground ginger, allspice, or a pinch of clove. Vanilla extract also enhances the warm, comforting flavors beautifully.

→ How should I serve this?

Serve warm as a side with roasted meats, poultry, or ham. It also works wonderfully as a vegetarian main course paired with a fresh green salad.