Classic Creamy Potato Salad

My neighbor handed me a bowl of her potato salad one summer afternoon, and I immediately understood why it had become legendary at every block party. There was something about the way the potatoes held onto the tangy dressing without falling apart, how the celery stayed crisp despite hours in the cooler. I asked for her secrets that day, and she laughed, telling me the real magic happens when you let the warm potatoes absorb the dressing. Now I make it her way, and it's become the dish people ask me to bring.

I remember bringing this to a family reunion where my cousin's husband—the guy who claims he "doesn't eat salad"—went back for thirds. He was so surprised that potato salad could taste this good that he started asking questions about every ingredient. Watching someone discover that good food changes minds was worth all the prep work.

Ingredients

• Waxy potatoes: They hold their shape and don't get grainy or waterlogged like floury varieties do, which means your salad stays elegant instead of turning into mash.
• Mayonnaise: This is your creamy base, and using quality mayo makes a noticeable difference in richness and flavor.
• Dijon mustard: Just a couple tablespoons adds sharpness that keeps the salad from tasting flat or one-dimensional.
• Apple cider vinegar: This brings brightness and a subtle sweetness that complements the earthiness of potatoes perfectly.
• Celery, red onion, and scallions: Together they create layers of crunch and flavor—the red onion adds color and bite, the celery stays crisp, and scallions give you a fresh, oniony note without overpowering.
• Fresh parsley: Don't skip this; it adds a light, herbaceous freshness that makes people wonder what the secret ingredient is.
• Hard-boiled eggs and pickles: These are optional, but they add protein and a briny punch that transforms the whole dish into something more interesting.

Instructions

Boil the potatoes until just tender:

Cut your potatoes into bite-sized cubes and drop them into cold, salted water—starting with cold water helps them cook evenly. Once they're boiling, set a timer for 10 to 15 minutes; you want them fork-tender but not falling apart. This is the moment you can smell them cooking, that starchy potato aroma filling your kitchen.

Build the dressing while potatoes cool:

Whisk together your mayonnaise, both mustards, vinegar, salt, pepper, and paprika in a large bowl until smooth and well combined. Don't rush this step; take a moment to taste a tiny bit on your finger and adjust the seasonings to your preference.

Combine while potatoes are still warm:

This is the secret: add the slightly cooled potatoes to the dressing while they still have warmth. They'll absorb the flavors so much better than cold potatoes would, creating that creamy, flavor-soaked texture everyone loves.

Fold in the vegetables gently:

Add your celery, red onion, scallions, and parsley, folding carefully so nothing breaks down into mush. You're looking for even distribution where every bite has a little bit of everything.

Add eggs and pickles if using:

If you're including hard-boiled eggs and dill pickles, fold them in now so they're evenly scattered throughout. Their flavors will marry with the rest as the salad sits.

Taste, adjust, and chill:

Before refrigerating, taste and add more salt, pepper, or vinegar if needed—the flavors will mellow slightly as it sits. Cover and let it rest in the fridge for at least an hour so the flavors can really come together.

Save to Pinterest

There's a moment that happens every time I make this, usually right before a gathering, when I taste it fresh and think it's perfect, then taste it again after it's been chilled and realize it's even better. The flavors have deepened, the textures have settled into harmony, and somehow it tastes like summer itself. That's when I know I've got it right.

The Secret of Good Potato Salad

Most disappointing potato salads fail because they're made with the wrong potatoes or because they're assembled cold. The potato matters more than people think—waxy varieties like red potatoes or fingerlings stay creamy and intact, while starchy potatoes fall apart into a gluey paste. The assembly timing matters just as much: combining warm potatoes with your dressing is what transforms this from a sad side dish into something worth remembering.

Variations and Substitutions

This recipe is forgiving and adaptable to what you have on hand or what your crowd prefers. If someone in your group prefers lighter food, swap half the mayonnaise for Greek yogurt and you'll get a tangier, fluffier result. For bacon lovers, crispy bacon bits stirred in at the end add smokiness and crunch that makes it feel completely different.

Make-Ahead and Storage Tips

This is one of those dishes that actually improves over a day or two in the refrigerator as the flavors meld and deepen. Store it in an airtight container and it will keep well for three to four days, making it perfect for meal prep or planning ahead for gatherings.

• Make it the day before serving for maximum flavor development and one less thing to worry about on party day.
• If it seems dry when you pull it out, refresh it with a drizzle of vinegar or a spoonful of mayo mixed in gently.
• Serve it straight from the fridge or let it sit out for 15 minutes before serving—both work beautifully depending on the weather and your preference.

Save to Pinterest

Potato salad might seem simple, but it's one of those dishes that reminds you how the smallest choices—the type of potato, the timing of assembly, the quality of your mayo—add up to something that feels nothing short of delicious. Make it once and you'll understand why people keep asking you to bring it.

Your Recipe Questions Answered

→ What type of potatoes work best for this dish?

Waxy potatoes, such as Yukon Gold or red potatoes, hold their shape well when cooked and are perfect for achieving the creamy yet tender texture.

→ Can I prepare the dish in advance?

Yes, chilling the dish for at least an hour helps the flavors meld and improves the overall taste.

→ How can I make this dish lighter?

Substitute half the mayonnaise with Greek yogurt for a lighter, tangier dressing without compromising creaminess.

→ Are there optional ingredients to enhance flavor?

Adding hard-boiled eggs and finely diced dill pickles adds extra texture and a subtle tangy flavor to the dish.

→ What are suitable serving suggestions?

This creamy potato side pairs well with grilled meats, roasted vegetables, or can be served chilled for picnics and barbecues.